Guatemala Twitter arrest brings local scandal to wider audience

A Guatemalan man is under house arrest for sending a Twitter message that incited “financial panic” last week. Police arrested 37-year-old Jean Anleu Fernandez last Tuesday but released him on bail overnight on condition he remains at home. Fernandez’s employer put up a loan for the $6500 fine ordered by a Guatemalan judge and his supporters are collecting PayPal donations to repay it. A new video shows him tweeting while in handcuffs.

Fernandez tweets under the label @jeanfer and last week he urged people in Guatemala to boycott a bank in a political scandal. He was arrested at home in the capital Guatemala City and had his computer seized after tweeting (in Spanish) people should withdraw cash from Banrural and “break the bank of the corrupt”. Fernandez tagged the message with ‘#escandalogt’ which refers to the alleged murder of prominent lawyer Rodrigo Rosenberg.

Rosenberg was shot dead last Sunday while riding his bicycle in Guatemala City. On Monday, he appeared in a youtube video in which he accused President Alvaro Colom, his wife and his personal secretary of ordering his own death. “If at this moment you are hearing or watching this message, it is because Alvaro Colom assassinated me,” said Rosenberg in the video. Rosenberg also accused Colom of Khalil Musa, a Guatemalan industrialist shot dead with his adult daughter a month ago. Musa was Rosenberg’s client.

Musa had been appointed by President Colom to the board of Banrural, a partly state-run rural bank. In the video Rosenberg said Musa was killed because he refused to co-operate in corrupt Banrural business deals. President Colom claimed he is “incapable” of ordering the murder. Colom has invited the UN and the FBI to investigate the affair.

The US confirmed the FBI have been asked to assist and authorities have also spoken to the International Commission Against Impunity in Guatemala (CICIG), a UN panel set up in 2007 to clean up corruption in the country. “I don’t know the motives Rodigro Rosenberg had to film that tape but if you see those who were involved in filming the tape you understand who they are…they are destabilisers,” said Colom.

Hundreds have taken to streets of the capital this week protesting Rosenberg’s death and demanding Colom’s resignation. Colom told Al Jazeera he had no intention of stepping down. “The people of Guatemala have the right to protest and ask for justice … but be careful of crossing the line,” he said. He won support from the Washington-based Organisation of American States (OAS) which passed a resolution on Wednesday approving support for Colom’s administration “in its obligation to preserve the institutions of democracy and the rule of law”.

Álvaro Colom is a centre-leftist who won the election in 2007, taking office in January 2008. His priority has been to address the tragic legacy left by the country’s 36 year civil war, which killed close to a quarter of a million Guatemalans and ended with the 1996 UN-brokered peace accords. In March he opened military archives to aid lawyers in a case against a former Guatemalan dictator for genocide and the government is collecting statements from war victims for future criminal cases against army and police officials accused of abuses during the war.

The Rosenberg allegations represent Colom’s biggest test in office. The lawyer claimed Colom and associates dragged his client Khalil Musa into the corruption scam. The head of the banking system, Genaro Pacheco, said Fernandez admitted sending the tweet about Banrural. Inciting financial panic is an offence in Guatemala. He will be held under house arrest pending trial.

Fernandez’s arrest has angered bloggers and has spawned several campaigns of solidarity, including the collection to pay for the fine. Many are unconvinced his tweet could have produced the panic claimed by the government. Blogger Jorge Mota asks why the authorities could move so quickly on this, but the more serious accusation from the Rosenberg video has yet to receive the same treatment. “One gets incriminated for murder by a video and one can deny everything, and of course the country’s impunity protects,” said Moto. “But one makes a comment on Twitter, and is arrested.”


3 thoughts on “Guatemala Twitter arrest brings local scandal to wider audience

  1. I’m no fan of a center-left government, but the whole series of events is too ‘neat’ for me to accept at face value. The effort to create a run on a bank (one supported by the government), adds credibility to the President’s claim this entire episode is an attempt to overthrow the government.

    As for Mr. Mota’s question, I would respond that a video, even one recorded by a now-deceased man, isn’t evidence, only allegation. In the case of @jeanfer, there was no doubt as to the culpability.

    1. Mark, I think you’ve got a point there. When I started looking at this, I could see it wasn’t as simple a case as I first thought it might be. I’m sympathetic to Colom’s difficulties and I agree the video is just an allegation – albeit a powerful one. However I can’t see how one Twitter message could lead to a run on the banks, particularly as Fernandez has no connection with the bank.

  2. It’s not every day you find a video or allegation like this, which is why it’s a big deal. In a country that has had so many problems with equal application of the law, they need it now more than ever and that’s why I hope to see deliberation and reason win out.

    It’s always easy to say how hard it is to believe that one tweet could cause any harm, but would you delay fixing a leak in a damn simply because it is only one, apparently insignificant one?

    The backdrop here is a country with massive problems and generations of inequality boiling below the surface.

    FYI: @jeanfer is out on bail and I suspect the charges will eventually disappear. I suspect the powers that be will consider the message to have been delivered.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s