Facebook and the media: Opening the gated community

One guaranteed way to make a newspaper headline writer’s day is to find an event with a tenuous connection to Facebook. If there is a chance that technology can be blamed for something, it will be. In the last few days we have Facebook murders, Facebook crime, Facebook rescues, Facebook bandits, illegal Facebook parties and even “Facebook for the dead”. This is lazy journalism though understandable the media should want to tap into the Internet’s biggest phenomenon. (photo by jurvetson)

Facebook’s growth shows little sign of slowing down. Founder Mark Zuckerberg said he still had big plans for the application when he announced last week Facebook had 300 million users which would make it the fourth largest country in the world. It is not difficult to believe it will soon overtake the US with its 3.1 million citizens to leave only China and India ahead of it. Zuckerberg is so confident, he thinks the company may even make money in 2010.

Zuckerberg says his mission is “to make the world more open and transparent by giving people the power to share information.” But while many have praised Facebook as part of the democratising trend of new media, there is a social exclusion aspect to it also. Facebook is the largest gated community in the world. Author Robert Putnam told fan culture guru Henry Jenkins while engagement with Facebook was primarily a social activity, there is a real “participation divide” that creates varying degrees of Internet engagement. Putnam found Facebookers practice what cultural anthropologists call “gating,” that is, the tendency to build physical/virtual, social, and cultural walls that are exclusive.

Within their own communities social network users are very generous. Zmags’ Joakim Ditlev found Facebook is the most popular sharing tool among digital readers with 38 percent using it to forward content with Twitter well back in second place on 9 percent. Ditley says Facebook’s casual way of communicating “seems to apply well” for sharing digital content.

Facebook’s communication tools are also eating away at time spent on email, instant messaging and discussion groups. Activities that used to be in email, such as posting videos or holiday photos are now migrating to Facebook. As ReadWriteWeb says Gen Yers “don’t even think of email as the place to connect with friends and family – that’s what social networks are for.”

People are leaving an enormous trail of data that could come back to haunt them. While embarrassing photos are an obvious problem, a look at a friend list can also reveal a great deal about the person. An experiment at Boston’s MIT found that simply by looking at a friend list, they could predict whether the person was gay. They did this with a software program that looked at the gender and sexuality of a person’s friends and made a prediction using statistical analysis. As the Boston Globe puts it: “if our friends reveal who we are, that challenges a conception of privacy built on the notion that there are things we tell, and things we don’t.”

In Australia, the notion of privacy has been challenged by a court case against prison officers who used a Facebook group to protest against privatisation of prisons. In October last year, six NSW corrections officers created a private group called “Suggestions to help big RON save a few clams”. But when Big RON – NSW Corrective Services Commissioner Ron Woodham – found out about the suggestions he threatened to fire them for “bullying” and “harassment”.

It did not take long for the media to label them The Facebook Six. Last week the Industrial Relations Commission decided their cases needed to be reheard after concerns of procedural unfairness. The lesson to be learnt about Facebook, as academic David Perlmutter stated recently, is that it is “a particularly dangerous weapon for self-injury because more than with many other social-networking sites, it is so easy to share an embarrassing admission or offensive quip.”

Some believe Facebook makes its users smarter. According to Dr Tracy Alloway from the University of Stirling in Scotland, the soc-med site is doing “wonders for working memory [and] improving…IQ scores”. While it is doubtful that the thousands who sign on every day are doing it to become smarter, its versatility is one of its most attractive features. The downside is that it gives news editors even more things to place next to “Facebook” in their next headline.

Advertisements

One thought on “Facebook and the media: Opening the gated community

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s