Carbon Tax: Which companies will pay?

This story started as I was writing an article on Monday for my paper about the carbon tax. The Government had released a vast amount of information on Sunday about their new proposal. I interviewed the local gas companies, Santos and Origin, a few weeks prior and was keen to write about the coal seam gas industry impact of the tax and local implications. In her speech on Sunday, Prime Minister Julia Gillard said 500 big companies would pay for every tonne of carbon they produce. Climate change minister Greg Combet confirmed it in one of his releases. I assumed the gas majors to would be on the list.
However after a quick look at the new government website “cleanenergyfuture” I was unable to find the list. ABC political correspondent Sabra Lane said those affected would be “mining, steel companies and aluminium manufacturers”. There was no mention of coal seam gas. So I set the task of finding the 500 to a keen young journalist who started here last week. I thought it might be a tough task for her because this is one of the more incendiary consequences of the legislation and therefore one the Government might not be keen to publicise. I gave her 15 minutes to find it.
After 10 minutes of silence, I realised this must be harder than I thought and I went looking for it again. I was no more successful than my new journo, so it was time to ask Twitter. Turns out it wasn’t obvious there either. “Good question” was the best response I got; others were on the line of “let us know if you find out.” In the end what we wrote in the newspaper was “precise information on which companies were in or out were not available when the Western Star went looking.”

Annabel Crabb found more precise information when she turned her attention to the problem yesterday. Crabb wondered who was in the Misfortune 500 and said the biggest companies may not be the biggest emitters of carbon. “Can we get a list?,” she asked. “No – you can’t” said the Government. The 500 companies are not an identified list but an estimate of how many companies in Australia would be caught by the scheme’s eligibility rules.

I eventually found the Government page that talks about the 500 companies. “Most are companies operating large facilities (with over 25,000 tonnes annual CO2-e emissions) that directly emit greenhouse gases, such as power stations, mines and heavy industry,” the site said. “Some are public authorities responsible for emissions from landfills.” A fact sheet gave a breakdown of where the companies were. NSW and Queensland had half the companies, 100 were involved in coal, 60 each in electricity and heavy industry, 50 in other fossil fuel and 40 in natural gas. I assumed the latter category covers my local companies, but could not confirm this as there were no company names in the fact sheet.

For political reasons, petrol and agriculture are exempt and Crabb explained other problems with the eligibility rules. “A company with 20 facilities each emitting 24,000 tonnes of CO2 a year would not be liable, while some poor boob with one factory emitting 26,000 tonnes of carbon dioxide and 19 clean green beansprout-fired tofu smelters would still have to cough up.”

Crabb also found the compulsory reporting done under the National Greenhouse and Energy Reporting Act 2007. The National Greenhouse and Energy Reporting on “Greenhouse and Energy Information 2009-2010” has a list of 300 companies that emit more than the 2009-10 annual threshold of 87,500 tonnes a year. It does not break the data down by facility but it is difficult to see how companies like Macquarie Generation (23.4 million tonnes), Delta Electricity (20.45m), CS Energy (16.8m), TRUenergy (15.6m), Blue Scope Steel (10.8m), Woodside Petroleum (8.4m), Alinta (7.8m), and Alcoa (6.75m) can avoid paying the tax. There were only 300 companies in this list, so 200 others need to be added.

Both of the CSG companies were on the list, Santos at 3.57m and Origin at 1.87m. So as I suspected all along – they will both likely be in the 500. At $23 a tonne I estimate Santos will have to pay $85m a year and Origin $43m. Macquarie Generation (getting their message out through the sympathetic Australian) are up for $538 billion. Despite what the Government said, it should not have been that hard to find out. Watch out too for fiddling along the edges as companies try to make the most of that “facilities” loophole.


4 thoughts on “Carbon Tax: Which companies will pay?

  1. That is great feedback. I own a Residential Insulation Products company and we sell high energy manufactured products to our customers. I would like to know if the products we purchase are going to be more expensive next year thanks to this great big tax grab.

    Naturally we are going to have to pass any increases to our customers, the end users being worse off home buyers.

  2. The following link (found in a few minutes)
    shows the list which also can be downloaded as
    LEPID for 2012-13 Financial year (XLS 28.9 kB) or
    LEPID for 2012-13 Financial year (CSV 13.5 kB)
    A link to the list (now outdated) was published online by SMH on May 4
    It appears you, your keen young journalist and some others could do with some lessons in searching with Google!

    1. Leigh, this article was written in July 2011. None of the documents you quote were available at that time.

  3. Yes – it does not seem possible to get a list of anywhere near 500 companies. The list released by the Gov initially had about 200 or so companies earlier this year and now we are being told it’s getting closer to 300 – but 200 are missing or were never in existence

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s