
Oliver St John Gogarty is probably best known these days for a pub named after him in the Temple Bar area of Dublin but he deserves to be better remembered. W.B. Yeats called Gogarty “one of the great lyric poets of the age” while former Liberal prime minister H.H. Asquith said he was “the wittiest man in London”. As Ulick O’Connor wrote in Oliver St John Gogarty: A Poet and his Times (1964), Gogarty was a classic Renaissance man; a poet, author, surgeon, athlete, statesman, and conversationalist. He formed friendships with the most influential people in early 20th century Ireland including Yeats, Trinity don J.P. Mahaffy, Sinn Fein founder Arthur Griffith, and James Joyce, until they had a spectacular falling out.
His father Henry Gogarty qualified as a doctor from Trinity College in 1867 and built up a successful practice in Dublin. Henry lived at Fairfield, a Queen Anne Manor in Glasnevin and he married Margaret Oliver in 1876. Oliver was their first child born in 1878 followed by Henry, Mary and Richard. Henry senior died in 1887 but left his family in comfort. Oliver attended Stonyhurst College in Lancashire but he resented its Jesuit conformity, calling it a “religious jail”. He returned to Ireland to study at Clongowes Wood, and then studied medicine at Dublin’s Royal University. He cycled during the day and drank with medical students at night. In six terms he passed only two exams and his dissatisfied mother moved him to Trinity. Here he fell under the influence of John Pentland Mahaffy, the greatest Egyptologist of his era, whose witticisms and epigrams were beloved of his students including Oscar Wilde. Mahaffy was proudly Anglo-Irish, believing they were superior to the English and were “as curious as the Germans while loathing their inelegance”.
While Trinity was a bastion of the Protestant Ascendency, it had a rebellious undercurrent. Wolfe Tone, Robert Emmet, Thomas Davis, William Smith O’Brien, Charles Gavan Duffy, and the Fenian Thomas Clark Luby, were all educated there. Gogarty loved Trinity and excelled in everything except medicine. He buckled down in his final year and achieved creditable results. Gogarty was a jester and prankster, infamously selling a drunken medical student to the Royal College of Surgeons as a corpse. Gogarty opposed the Boer War, and sent in an anonymous poem to the snobbish Tory social magazine Irish Society, seemingly an ode to “The Gallant Irish Yeoman / Home from the War has come”. But when read vertically the first letter of each line spelled out “the whores will be busy”. Gogarty’s forte was cycling and he won nearly every college race in 1899. He won the 20-mile championship of Ireland in 53 minutes 35 seconds, a record that lasted many years. As one competitor said, you had to watch him like a hawk in races. “If you took your eye off him for a second he was past in a flash, with his cry of “Up, up Balrothery” (their training grounds.) He was suspended for bad language in 1901 and never raced again. He took an interest instead in the Irish literary renaissance. Though his medical progress was slow his poetry won many Trinity prizes, influenced by Mahaffy, and fellow classical scholar Robert Tyrrell, who became close friends, and educated him in Greek and Roman civilisations.
Dublin was another formative influence on his elegance and panache. He admired the 18th century “Bucks”, high-society rakes who fought duels and caroused at the Hellfire Club. Joyce painted Gogarty as “Buck” Mulligan, “a primrose-vested gallant against the picaresque society of lower-middle class Dublin”. Gogarty’s bravery was renowned and he had rescued several drowning men from the Liffey for which he gained medals from the Royal Humane Society.
Ireland was in intellectual and political ferment in the early 20th century. The works of Yeats, Synge and Lady Gregory graced the Abbey Theatre, Arthur Griffith gave the Irish independence movement an intellectual foundation, James Connolly and James Larkin founded the Irish trade union movement, the Gaelic League renewed enthusiasm for the Irish language, while home rule prospects seemed bright under John Redmond’s Irish Party. Other important influences were two Georges, novelist George Moore, and writer George Russell, known as “A.E.” who developed occult study in Ireland. Gogarty met them through Yeats whom he regarded with awe. Yeats worked on an adaptation of Sophocles’ Oedipus in 1908. He consulted Gogarty on classical sources and invited him to Moore’s lively literary salons. Gogarty said Yeats read from his play Deirdre, “his voice sets all vibrating as he sways like a Druid with his whole soul chanting”. Moore caused a sensation when he returned to Dublin to join the literary revival after being the darling of London and Paris. Moore was a great talker but was outdone by the undergraduate Gogarty. Moore called him the “Arch Mocker”, always with a witticism or a new ballad or limerick. A.E. was equally impressed, saying Gogarty had a “reckless imagination”.
Gogarty and his medical friends hung out in Nighttown, Dublin’s red light district, where they were welcomed for their healing powers. Gogarty befriended “the brothel-keepers, bullies, and frequenters” and absorbed the language of the underworld. The Legion of Mary clamped down on the “kips” in 1924 and Gogarty lamented its passing in his poem The Hay Hotel (the Cavendish Row establishment that served late night coffee and crubeens). “There’s nothing left but ruin now / Where once the crazy cabfuls roared”. Joyce portrayed Nighttown in Ulysses where Bloom called on his “old friend, Dr Malachi Mulligan, sex specialist to give medical testimony”. Gogarty met Joyce in 1901, and they had much in common beside a love of red lights. Joyce was impressed by Gogarty’s memory for classical verse while Gogarty loved Joyce’s singing voice. They both hated Dublin middle class hypocrisy. They were similar in appearance and became a familiar sight walking together. Gogarty called Joyce many names including “wandering Aengus” and “Kinch” in imitation of the cutting sound of a knife. When they left Ireland in 1903 to study abroad, (Joyce to Paris, Gogarty to Oxford), they communicated regularly. Gogarty’s letters are at Cornell University while Joyce’s were destroyed when anti-Treaty forces burned Gogarty’s house in the civil war. At Oxford, Gogarty was in constant demand as an entertaining Irishman. He met humanist George Bell, later Bishop of Chichester, and they retained a lifelong friendship.
When Gogarty and Joyce returned to Ireland, they lived together at Sandycove’s Martello Tower, with its inspiring view over Dublin Bay. Joyce worked in a local school and his salary helped pay the rent. Gogarty spent most time swimming at the Forty Foot bathing pool, and Joyce occasionally accompanied him. As the opening chapter of Ulysses showed, the pair bickered. Gogarty was annoyed by the airs and graces Joyce gained in Paris. Gogarty told a friend that Joyce’s “want of generosity became to me inexcusable”. Joyce left Dublin hurriedly with young Nora Barnacle, whom he later married. As they settled in Trieste, he corresponded with Gogarty. When Joyce returned on holidays in 1909, he met Gogarty briefly. They gave differing accounts of what happened. Gogarty said that Joyce stared out the window at a rose garden and then enigmatically said “Is this your revenge?” before walking out. According to Joyce, Gogarty made a long confusing speech which ended “Do you want me to go to Hell?” to which Joyce replied, “I bear you no ill will,” but added “You and I of six years ago are both dead”. It’s not clear which version is true, but they never met again.
Gogarty first met Arthur Griffith in 1899. Gogarty revered him, and Griffith was one of the few people spared his acid tongue. Griffith admired Gogarty for his athleticism and found his class background useful. Griffith loved good conversation and basked in Gogarty’s wit. Gogarty was soon writing for Griffith’s newspaper United Irishman. Griffith held the first annual convention of Sinn Fein in 1905 where Gogarty said the Irish were “the victims and tools of the most disgraceful government in the world”. The United Irishman printed his fiery speech in full. Trinity friends were alarmed at Gogarty’s extremism and were worried authorities might take action against him.
They never did and Gogarty graduated in 1907 after 10 years of study, including six months of living in hospital to gain certificates in obstetrics, medicine and surgery. He married Galway woman Martha Duane who gave birth son Oliver in July 1907. The newly qualified doctor moved to Vienna to do postgraduate work to specialise in ear, nose and throat surgery, taking Martha but leaving newborn Oliver with a nurse in Dublin. Gogarty loved Vienna as “the most civilised city in Europe” and enjoyed its excellent training opportunities. He returned to Dublin in 1908 and worked at Richmond Hospital. Hospital work was unpaid but brought lucrative referrals through contacts with GPs. Routine Ear, Nose and Throat work took little time and Gogarty got the reputation of being a top notch surgeon who worked at great speed, “lightning with his hands”. Second son Dermot was born in 1908 followed by daughter Brenda in 1912.
Gogarty settled in Ely Place and bought an expensive Rolls Royce which became well known in Dublin. Some considered Gogarty’s driving suicidal, and he would deliberately skid his car in the rain. He remained a church-goer, though an unorthodox one (one woman at Mass saw his lips move as if in prayer but found he was reading from Horace’s Odes). He admired the Irish Christian Brothers’ free secondary education and he retained a lifelong friendship with Dr Michael Fogarty, long-term Bishop of Killaloe, as “the reverend Dr Fogarty and the irreverend Dr Gogarty.” Every Friday, Gogarty hosted a literary evening. Guests including Yeats, Moore, AE, Augustus John, and Horace Plunkett enjoyed the “stimulating seriousness and wit of their host”. Gogarty was a regular at The Bailey in Anne St. where he smoked cheroots, sang ballads, and told stories. Rapt attendees included talented young MP Tom Kettle, who matched Gogarty for epigrams. Gogarty studied with Kettle at Clongowes and admired the “laughter in his soul”. Another Bailey frequenter, Piaras Beaslai, said Gogarty swiftly moved from topic to topic “telling a number of anecdotes, decorous and indecorous”.
The 1912 Home Rule Bill was initially welcomed by extremists like Griffith and Patrick Pearse. But tensions in Ireland grew after Ulster Unionist resistance and the formation of paramilitary groups. The Ulster and Irish Volunteers imported arms into Ireland, and the division dismayed Gogarty. He told his friend Lord Dunsany he admired the Irish Volunteers but “did not wish to join when others were joining for party-political motives”. When the First World War broke out, home rule went on the backburner. Redmond supported the war effort, which a splinter group of Irish Volunteers opposed. Gogarty agreed with Griffith that support of the war needed to be tied to immediate home rule. When the Easter Rising broke out in 1916, Gogarty was driving to Dublin and armed police stopped him at Mullingar. With patients to see on Easter Tuesday he managed to get back to the city and found out that Pearse and Connolly were at the GPO. Gogarty told Moore that the unpopular rising would serve only to redeem the credit of the British Army which was failing in Europe. But after the executions, the public mood changed, as expressed in Gogarty’s poem The Rebels. “Death withholds them more / Separate for ever and aloof”.
In 1917 Gogarty bought an isolated Connemara mansion on the edge of the Atlantic Ocean. Renvyle House became a haven from city life. He entertained distinguished visitors and painter Augustus John captured its colours in his landscapes. It was a far cry from the city slums which Gogarty wrote about in his play Blight: The Tragedy of Dublin. It caused a sensation at its Abbey Theatre opening. The Irish Times said it “revealed the horrors of slumdom”. Gogarty wrote it under the pseudonym Alpha and Omega. Gogarty was Alpha while judge Joseph O’Connor, who provided anecdotal material, was Omega. The play’s criticism of the government and the war effort was controversial, and, despite its popularity, Lady Gregory ended its run after 10 days, under external pressure but influenced Sean O’Casey’s later work.
In 1918 the war was going badly. Ireland seemed on the brink of revolution when Lloyd George proposed conscription in the country. When elections were held in December 1918, the Irish Home Rule party was wiped out, and Sinn Fein won an overwhelming victory. They followed Griffith’s abstention policy and the First Dáil sat in Dublin in January 1919. It was suppressed and there were thousands of arrests. Gogarty produced another Abbey play called A Serious Thing, released under the name “Gideon Ousely”. Its plot about the Roman occupation of Palestine was a thinly disguised satire of British rule in Ireland. Roman soldiers wore khaki because, as the program notes said, “it seemed the most appropriate uniform”. Ireland descended into terror and violence. Gogarty was lucky that when the Black and Tans briefly arrested him, they did not find a cigarette case full of newspaper clipping detailing their atrocities. Gogarty’s Ely Place home was a safehouse for I.R.A. leaders on the run. His daughter Brenda remembers seeing Michael Collins many times. Her parents worried that she might blurt out at school that a strange man was staying at the house. Gogarty used his car to assist a jailbreak, taking fugitives “at rare speed” away from Mountjoy. His bravery was recognised and almost as important, according to Collins’s 2IC Richard Mulcahy, was the social milieu Gogarty provided. “Gogarty’s house was a valuable meeting ground for people of different beliefs and creeds”, Mulcahy said, a place where Republicans could meet Unionists and landed gentry who differed politically, but who “had the common good of Ireland at heart”.
Gogarty played a cameo role in the 1921 peace negotiations. Griffith asked Gogarty to drive him to Kingstown where South African general Jan Smuts arrived for talks. Griffith wanted to brief Smuts before he got into the hands of Castle officials. Smuts got wind of Griffith’s plan and hid in a lifeboat while Griffith and Gogarty searched the ship for him. Later at the Mansion House, Smuts told Irish leaders not to try for a republic. “I tried a Republic and it was a failure,” he said. Collins and Griffith led a delegation to treaty talks in London. In an October 1921 letter, Gogarty was pessimistic and thought Ireland could not be freed before Egypt or India. “There will be a war here in any case and it will take six months to meet it and more,” he wrote. Gogarty’s words proved prophetic but it would be Irish fighting against each other, not against England, after the divisive Treaty was signed in December. Gogarty supported the Treaty and became close to Collins. Gogarty recognised that Collins was a man of action, but he “loved beautiful things and had a warm sympathy for Art”. Collins loved Gogarty’s humour and they would drive to take tea at Beechpark, the mountainside home of vice president W.T. Cosgrave. Cosgrave admired them both as men of courage and said, “that pair of rascals took more delight in shocking me than in talking serious business”.
Double tragedy struck in August. First, Griffith died of a brain haemorrhage and Gogarty had to embalm his great friend. “Arthur Griffith justified Ireland,” he eulogised. “It remains for Ireland to become worthy of Arthur Griffith.” Ten days later Collins was killed in an ambush in Cork. Ireland was traumatised by his death, and Gogarty embalmed another great friend. With fine skill he hid the gaping wound in the back of Collins’ head. Gogarty’s grief came out in a poem when he asked “What Cain has caught his country by the throat?” The civil war became increasingly bitter and there were numerous summary executions. Rebel leader Liam Lynch ordered that the cabinet, Pro-Treaty TDs, High Court judges, and “aggressive Free State supporters” were to be shot on sight. In December the government created a parliamentary upper house and Yeats and Gogarty were named senators. Gogarty became a Republican target. He was taking a bath on January 20, 1923 when armed gunmen broke into his home and pressed a gun into his ribs. “Isn’t it a good thing to die in a flash, Senator?” a gunmen said, as they bundled him into a car. Gogarty kept his wits and amused captors with his humour. They took him to a house on the banks of the Liffey near the Salmon Weir. Gogarty asked if he could go outside and when he did he threw his coat over an assailant and jumped into the freezing and flooded river. Gogarty survived the shock, though thought he might suffer a heart attack. Swept on by floods, he could barely breathe, but grabbed an overhead branch and pulled himself to shore. He dragged himself to Phoenix Park police barracks where he could merely hiccup at the sentry. He was revived with brandy, but was still in shock when a doctor arrived. “I am Senator Oliver St John Gogarty” is all he could say. Later, Gogarty fulfilled a vow he made while immersed in the raging torrent that he would present two swans in thanksgiving if he made it to safety. Cruel poems satirised Gogarty’s wild adventure. “Faith, thin, Oliver St John Gogarty, ye’ve too much bounce to sink”. He remained in danger, and carried a revolver. Consulting room patients were examined by eight guards before they could see him. In May 1923 he had to move his practice to London, though he returned to Dublin to fulfil senatorial duties. The war finally ended and Eamon de Valera was arrested, Gogarty complaining that Dev had “done more damage to Ireland than Cromwell“.
Gogarty’s dazzling conversation made him the toast of London intellectuals, politicians, and royalty. Dissident republicans threatened to kill him if he didn’t resign from the Senate, a threat Gogarty called “impertinent”. A visit to Bristol reminded him of home, and in 1924 he returned to Dublin. He got involved in the organisation of the Taillteann Games, a revival of an ancient sporting festival, open to athletes of Irish descent. Gogarty’s task was to invite international “worthies” to the Games. He gathered an eclectic list of people he deemed had sufficient personality, including author G.K. Chesterton, Indian cricketer Prince Ranjitsinhji, architect Edwin Lutyens, and Scottish writer Compton Mackenzie. Gogarty led visitors on morning hikes to Howth before watching the daily games. He finished third in archery while winning a gold medal for poetry with his book An Offering of Swans. The collection contains a preface written by Yeats, who recounted how Gogarty asked if anyone had spare cygnets as he was “at a loss for birds to present to the Liffey”. He finally procured swans from Lady Leconfield’s Petworth House lake in West Sussex and held a presentation ceremony opposite the Salmon Weir where he escaped from the river in 1922. The Dublin legend persists that all swans on the Liffey are descended from Gogarty’s breeding pair.
In the Senate, Gogarty proposed investment in roads which he saw as replacing rail traffic and advocated an Irish merchant marine. He pushed for new housing to replace Dublin’s notorious tenement slums. He supported action against Republican dissidents and introduced a Public Safety Bill after Kevin O’Higgins’ murder in 1927. An admirer from afar, Winston Churchill, called Gogarty “a figure from the Antique, cast in bronze”.
Gogarty added a new string to his bow when he discovered flying. He took pilot lessons at Baldonnel Airport with the Irish Air Force and used his charm to gain access to their planes. “Ah St John could get anything he wanted” said one officer. “You couldn’t refuse him”. Soon he was flying across the sea to perform operations in London. In 1928 a student of Rodin offered to do a sculpture of him. Gogarty flew to Paris, sat with the sculptor for eight hours, then flew back to Dublin at first light to receive patients that morning. He and fellow pilot Lady Heath flew to an isolated Mayo beach for a swim but the plane failed on soft sand, and they were stuck on an off-shore island for several days. When Joyce heard about it, he said “I am glad to see Buck Mulligan is unhurt”. Gogarty formed the first Irish Aero Club in 1928. When he went to California in 1932, he loved flying from Los Angeles to San Francisco in two hours. America may go on ruling the air, he told one correspondent, “if the over-weaning confidence of her Admirals does not end in dashing the whole of our civilisation against the shores of Japan”.
The de Valera government abolished the Senate, claiming to extricate Ireland from “the paralysing dilemma of the Treaty”. Gogarty regarded it as an attempt to conciliate proletarian elements and called it “the worship of mud”. With his senatorial career doomed, he launched a ferocious attack on De Valera’s “peevishness and megalomania” saying he had betrayed American ideals of democracy. The Senate was dissolved in 1936 and though the 1937 constitution conjured up a new rubber stamp upper house, Gogarty was not among its members. As war loomed again, he published three books of verse and three prose works, including his memoir As I Was Going Down Sackville St (1936). His growing fame affected his medical practice as patients worried he might write about their experiences.
Gogarty was sued for libel over his memoir. Henry Morris Sinclair claimed that one passage about an usurer who enticed small girls into his office for sex had defamed him because Gogarty said the usurer passed on his predilection to his grandchildren, of which he was one. The case caused a sensation in Dublin. Gogarty was accused of having “a pen dipped in the scourging of a putrid and immoral mind”. A surprising witness against him was playwright Samuel Beckett who identified Sinclair from the passage in the book. Gogarty almost got off the hook when the judge claimed the authorship of the book was not proven, but the plaintiff’s lawyer called Gogarty to testify. Gogarty admitted he wrote the book and knew Sinclair and his grandfather. Gogarty’s lawyer admitted defamation but it was so obscure as to be obvious only to Sinclair’s inner circle. The jury found in favour of Sinclair and awarded £900 damages and costs. Gogarty never forgave Beckett and later called Waiting for Godot “nothing but a long wail”.
When war broke out, Gogarty returned to America and made a good living writing articles and giving lectures. He returned to Dublin in 1945 and found it leisurely after the pace of New York. But he had lost his medical clientele and with no source of income he returned to America, where he lived for another decade. Ulick O’Connor said he met Gogarty on his final visit to Ireland in 1956, and he looked slim and erect at 76. They walked the streets together “while he talked the whole time, except when he stopped to meet old acquaintances whom he greeted with exceptional charm”. O’Connor handed Gogarty a boyish photo of him in his cycling days. “He took it with interest, put it in his wallet, and then was gone,” O’Connor recalled. “It was as if for a moment I had revived a past which he did not want to think about if he was returning to America.” Gogarty decided to retire to Ireland but was taken ill with a heart attack in New York. With his old friend W.T. Cosgrave urging him to look after the state of his soul, he took last rites before he died on September 22, 1957. His body was flown to Ireland and he was buried at Renvyle in front of close friends and family. The wandering Aengus had finally found rest.



















